White Lily Cookie/Story (2024)

Forgotten Academy & Hall of Enlightenment[]

As students in the Blueberry Yogurt Academy, White Lily Cookie and Pure Vanilla Cookie researched the origin and creation of Cookies of their own volition, to the point that they broke numerous academy rules and attempted to create living Cookies. Pure Vanilla Cookie eventually puts the research to an end, while White Lily Cookie continues to study by herself, her experiments ultimately converting the academy's inhabitants into spirits by accident.

White Lily Cookie then spent a long time repenting for the accident, and did not see Pure Vanilla Cookie again until his coronation at the founding of the Vanilla Kingdom. She appeared to gain the Soul Jam of the Light of Freedom during this time, and would later join the other Ancient Heroes in bringing peace to the land of Earthbread.

Time in the Faerie Kingdom[]

White Lily Cookie would regularly set off on her own without a word to the other Ancient Heroes, pursuing her original desire to understand the origins and purpose of Cookies in order to build a better world for Cookiekind. She would eventually travel to Beast-Yeast, where a chance encounter with a wounded Silverbell Cookie allowed her to entire the mythical Faerie Kingdom. There, she aided the Faeries in repairing the seal in the Silver Tree that kept the Beasts imprisoned, preventing "The Great Calamity" by strengthening the Silver Tree with magical vines. This would earn her the eternal gratitude of the Faeries, who henceforth considered her one of their own.

Although her time in the Faerie Kingdom was happy, she eventually grew impatient with their long-lasting celebrations. She discovered information regarding the Witch's Banquet in the Faerie Kingdom Library; determined to ask the Witches the answers to her questions, she set out in the night when all the residents of the Faerie Kingdom were asleep. However, Elder Faerie Cookie appeared in her way and tried to convince her that the Banquet was too dangerous for any Cookie, asking her to instead stay in the Faerie Kingdom and guarantee peace for the Cookie World in doing so. Instead, White Lily Cookie promised him that she would never lose her love for the Cookie World regardless of what truths she discovered at the Witches' Banquet, seeing that love as her own weapon to protect the world with. Seeing that there was no changing her mind, Elder Faerie Cookie gave her a piece of Moonstone to travel back to the Faerie Kingdom in case of peril.

Tragedy at the Tower[]

White Lily Cookie traveled to the Witches' Banquet on the Night of the Witches to finally discover the answers to her questions. There, she sees the Witches celebrating by devouring Cookies they had baked, and realizes there that the Cookies were originally made to be eaten. Overcome with terror, surrounded by voiceless expressionless Cookies, and unable to accept this fate, she stumbles and falls into the Ultimate Dough, where her body was split into two and the Light of Freedom was shattered. One half, full of rage and darkness, became Dark Enchantress Cookie and devoted herself to burning the world of "eat or eaten" to the ground. The other half, refusing to abandon her commitment to Cookiekind, was transported from the Witch's Banquet to the Faerie Kingdom via the Moonstone, a lifeless husk that the Faeries would protected in a magical glass coffin. The remnants of the Light of Freedom protected what was left of White Lily Cookie, even as her soul was scattered all across the world.

One of the these soul fragments may have been the White Lily Cookie that GingerBrave's party encounters was revealed to be an illusory fragment of her past, brought to life when Dark Enchantress Cookie was imprisoned. This fragment of White Lily Cookie's past sought out her missing memories, and eventually followed the party to Dark Enchantress Cookie's moonstone prison deep with the Blueberry Yogurt Academy, which they broke open under the assumption that they were freeing White Lily Cookie. The remnant of White Lily Cookie disappeared as Dark Enchantress Cookie was released.

Secrets of the Silver Kingdom[]

When the vines protecting the Silver Tree begin to wither due to Dark Enchantress Cookie's magic, Elder Faerie Cookie performed the Ritual of Life to bring White Lily Cookie back, using both the collected remnants of the Light of Freedom and his own Life Powder. Upon waking up and recovering, White Lily Cookie was initially unable accept her revival, being fully aware of the acts her evil self had committed around Earthbread during her slumber. Elder Faerie Cookie assured her that her soul and spirit would never falter, having lit the branches of the Silver Tree after all this time while still preserving what was left of the Light of Freedom. Still overcome with the idea of her own fall from grace, she removed herself from the scene to have some time alone.

When GingerBrave approached White Lily Cookie, she asked him if he was upset at her for leading him to free Dark Enchantress Cookie. GingerBrave retorted that Dark Enchantress Cookie had used both of them for her own ends, and that despite their shared origins, White Lily Cookie's love for all Cookiekind in her heart made her different from Dark Enchantress Cookie. White Lily Cookie then asked GingerBrave if he knew the reason why Cookies were first created, to which he answers that he had never really given the idea thought, since the answer would not change his life or the lives of his friends. White Lily Cookie asked again if he had never felt the need to know his purpose, prompting GingerBrave to ask the same question back, saying that he didn't need a special reason to enjoy life. Understanding that GingerBrave was free to choose what to do with his life, White Lily Cookie tells him that her life may well have turned out differently had they met sooner.

White Lily Cookie spoke with Pure Vanilla Cookie to tell him that she would fight by his side to go against Dark Enchantress Cookie to repent for her crimes against Earthbread, determined to keep her promise to Elder Faerie Cookie to never lose her loved for the Cookie World.